IgoUgo

Key West Pizza Restaurants

Top 10 Restaurants in Key West

  1. Blue Heaven Restaurant
  2. Sloppy Joe's Bar
  3. Hard Rock Cafe
  4. Crabby Dick's
  5. El Meson de Pepe on Mallory Square
  6. Grand Cafe Key West
  7. El Siboney Restaurant
  8. Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville
  9. La Te Da
  10. José''s Cantina

Filter by Cuisine

Avg. User Rating

Price

Search

 

Top Deals for Key West

Save Up To 53%
Hotel Freebies + Great Rates, Breakfast For Two
priceline.com
Book by April 30, 2025
Save Up To 52%
Hotel Freebies + Great Rates, Free Breakfast, Resort Credit
priceline.com
Book by April 30, 2025
Save Up To 30%
Hotel Freebies + Great Rates, Free Breakfast For Two
priceline.com
Book by October 7, 2025
Save Up To 36%
Enjoy Special Rates In The Heart Of Key West
priceline.com
Book by October 31, 2025
See All Key West Restaurants
  • 1-10 of 19 Key West Restaurants

New York Pizza & Pasta Garden

Cuisine: Pizza, Café

Quote: Julie and I went to Key West in July of 2005 to get married. We had booked another restaurant for our reception. One thing led to another, including a hurricane, and the next thing we knew NY Pizza was hosting… Read More

Mr Z's

Cuisine: Pizza, Italian

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Been there, done that? Do tell us about it! Submit a review of this Key West restaurant today.

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #70 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    3 of 5 stars
  • Add to Trip

Popular Hotels In Key West

La Mer And Dewey House User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
Pier House Resort and Caribbea... User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
Almond Tree Inn User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
Hyatt Key West Resort and Mari... User Rating 4 out of 5 stars

Ray's Pizza

Cuisine: Italian, Pizza

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Hi there! No one's reviewed this Key West restaurant yet. If you've been, we'd love to hear about it! Submit the first review today.

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #101 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    3 of 5 stars
  • Price:
    3 out of 5
  • Add to Trip

Big John's Pizza

Cuisine: Sandwiches, Pizza

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Been there, done that? Do tell us about it! Submit a review of this Key West restaurant today.

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #103 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    3 of 5 stars
  • Add to Trip

Angelina's Pizzeria

Cuisine: Pizza

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Been there, done that? Do tell us about it! Submit a review of this Key West restaurant today.

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #111 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    2 of 5 stars
  • Add to Trip

The Upper Crust

Cuisine: Italian, Pizza

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Been there, done that? Do tell us about it! Submit a review of this Key West restaurant today.

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #136 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    2 of 5 stars
  • Price:
    3 out of 5
  • Add to Trip

Upper Crust Pizzeria

Cuisine: Pizza

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Hmmm, it appears we could use a review of this Key West restaurant. Any chance you've been and want to help us out? Submit a review and thousands of travelers will have you to thank!

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #140 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    2 of 5 stars
  • Price:
    1 out of 5
  • Add to Trip

Popular Hotels In Key West

DoubleTree Grand Key Resort User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
Orchid Key Inn User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
Heron House User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
Casa Marina Resort User Rating 4 out of 5 stars

Tower of Pizza

Cuisine: Pizza

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Have you been to this Key West restaurant? Tell other travelers what to expect. Submit a review today!

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #153 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    2 of 5 stars
  • Add to Trip

Big John's Pizza Pasta & Subs

Cuisine: Pizza

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Been there, done that? Do tell us about it! Submit a review of this Key West restaurant today.

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #167 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    2 of 5 stars
  • Price:
    3 out of 5
  • Add to Trip

Sbarro

Cuisine: American, Pizza, Italian

This Key West restaurant has no photos. Upload the first!

Have you been to this Key West restaurant? Tell other travelers what to expect. Submit a review today!

Be the first traveler to say you've been.

  • #188 most popular
    Key West restaurants
  • Avg. User Rating:
    2 of 5 stars
  • Price:
    1 out of 5
  • Add to Trip

Popular Hotels In Key West

Sheraton Suites Key West All S... User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
Crowne Plaza La Concha User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
Best Western Hibiscus Motel User Rating 4 out of 5 stars
La Te Da Hotel Key West User Rating 4 out of 5 stars

Submit Your Reviews of Key West Pizza restaurants

Do you know the best Pizza restaurants in Key West, Florida? We're always looking for more reviews and photos of Key West Pizza restaurants. Contribute yours today.

Key West Travel Guide